Estate Litigation

Probate & Estate Litigation in Michigan

Estate litigation is a specialized area of law that involves legal disputes over a deceased individual’s assets/inheritance.

These legal issues often stem from trustee misconduct, removal of beneficiaries, or other problems involving the probate of an estate.

Sean J Nichols, PLLC specializes in Michigan estate litigation cases. We have the knowledge, dedication, and experience to represent you during these complex and emotional disputes.

We specialize in many aspects of estate litigation including:

Estate Litigation Involving Trusts

In Michigan, Trustees have specific duties and liabilities under the Michigan Trust Code. These duties and liabilities include:

  • Impartiality between beneficiaries
  • Administration of the trust for the benefit of beneficiaries
  • The duty to carefully administer the trust in accordance with the written terms
  • The duty to keep beneficiaries informed
A Michigan Revocable Living Trust laying on a desk with a judges gavel above it symbolizing estate and trust litigation

Basically, trustees are responsible for handling the trust in accordance with terms written within the document. Furthermore, they’re responsible for keeping detailed accountings and reports of the assets within the trust. Finally, they’re responsible for handling the trust in an honest way that doesn’t show impartiality or self-serving for their own personal gain.

When a Trustee violates these duties, this is commonly referred to as Breach of Fiduciary Duty. In these cases, a trust may be contested and enter into litigation.

At Sean J Nichols, PLLC we handle various types of estate litigation cases involving trust disputes. These include:

  • Breach of fiduciary duty
  • Removal of beneficiaries
  • Defending trustee’s against claims
  • Undue influence and misrepresentation
  • Lack of testamentary capacity
  • Issues with accounting and reporting
  • Issues with formalities (i.e. if the trust was improperly signed of executed)
  • Disputes among beneficiaries
  • Removal of trustees

Estate Litigation Involving Wills

When someone passes away in Michigan, the will dictates who should receive assets and inheritance of the deceased individual. Unfortunately, this isn’t always cut and dry and in some cases, a dispute may be filed against the will itself or the process with how the will is administered.

Examples of Michigan estate litigation cases involving contested wills include:

A Michigan Last Will and Testament laying on a desk with a judges gavel above it symbolizing estate litigation for wills
  • Issues with formalities (i.e. the will was improperly witnessed, signed, or executed)
  • Lack of testamentary capacity
  • Removal of beneficiaries
  • Removal of personal representatives
  • Undue influence over the settlor
  • Fraud or misrepresentation
  • The will was signed or executed “under duress”
  • Existence of a subsequent will

Grounds for Contesting an Estate or Trust in Michigan

Disagreeing with the way an estate is distributed is not by itself enough to invalidate a will or trust in Michigan. A successful challenge generally requires a recognized legal basis. These typically include lack of testamentary capacity, undue influence, fraud or misrepresentation, duress, improper execution, revocation or the existence of a later valid estate-planning document.

For wills, Michigan law sets a specific standard for testamentary capacity. Under MCL 700.2501, the person making the will must have sufficient mental capacity to be able to understand that the document controls the disposition of property after death as well as knowing the nature and extent of that property and reasonably understand the nature and effect of signing the will. In a contested will proceeding, Michigan law generally places the burden on the contestant to establish lack of testamentary intent or capacity, show that the will was made with undue influence or under duress, or show that it was otherwise fraudulent.

It should be noted that undue influence is more than ordinary persuasion, advice or a close personal relationship. Michigan courts have described it as influence strong enough to overpower the decedent’s free choice and cause the person to act against his or her own wishes. Evidence of this may include the decedent’s dependence on another person, a fiduciary or confidential relationship or unusual changes to estate documents. It also can include isolation from family members, communications surrounding the signing of the document, medical evidence and the circumstances under which the will or trust was prepared and executed.

Deadlines and Evidence in Estate Litigation

Beneficiaries, trustees, personal representatives or any other interested parties should not assume that an estate or trust dispute can be addressed at any time. Michigan law applies different filing deadlines depending on the type of claim involved, making it important to identify the dispute and applicable limitation period as early as possible.

For example, under MCL 700.7604, a proceeding challenging a trust that was revocable at the settlor’s death generally must be filed within two years after the settlor’s death or six months after the trustee provides the statutory notice required by the law, whichever comes first. Breach-of-trust claims are governed by different rules. Under MCL 700.7905, a beneficiary may have only one year to bring certain claims after receiving a report that adequately discloses the potential breach and explains the applicable filing period.

Evidence can also play a major role in Michigan estate litigation. Relevant materials may include earlier wills and trusts, amendments or codicils. In addition to this, medical records, emails, text messages, financial records, trustee accountings, attorney drafting files, witness testimony, and records of asset transfers or beneficiary changes can also be considered evidence. Michigan probate proceedings may use civil discovery procedures to obtain this evidence.

Because both evidence and filing rights can be lost due to delays, seeking legal guidance early can help preserve important information and determine which deadlines apply, ensuring the best possible legal outcome.

Estate Litigation Process in Michigan

Estate litigation can involve several stages depending on the nature of the dispute, the parties involved and the complexity of the estate itself. While every case is different, understanding the general process can help beneficiaries, personal representatives, trustees and other interested parties know what to expect when a dispute arises.

Identifying the Estate Dispute

The first step is determining the nature of the dispute and whether there are legal grounds to pursue a claim. For example, a beneficiary may believe that a will was created under undue influence, that the deceased lacked the mental capacity to execute an estate planning document or that a personal representative or trustee has failed to properly manage estate assets. Reviewing wills, trusts, financial records, accountings, correspondence and other relevant documents can help determine the appropriate course of action.

Filing or Responding to a Claim

If the dispute cannot be resolved informally, an interested party may seek relief through the appropriate Michigan probate court. Depending on the circumstances, this could involve contesting a will, challenging the actions of a fiduciary or requesting an accounting audit. It could even escalate to the point of seeking the removal of a personal representative or trustee entirely.

Any other parties involved in the estate will generally have an opportunity to respond to the allegations. Because estate disputes can involve several beneficiaries and fiduciaries with competing interests, litigation may become increasingly complex as the case progresses.

Evidence Gathering and Dispute Resolution

During estate litigation, the parties may gather evidence to support their respective positions. Relevant evidence could include estate planning documents, medical records and financial information. Additionally things such as witness testimony can be considered as well as any communications with family members and records showing how estate assets were managed.

Some disputes may ultimately be resolved through negotiation or an agreement between the parties. When an acceptable resolution cannot be reached, the matter may proceed before the probate court, where a judge can determine the parties’ rights and order an appropriate resolution.

Common Questions

What is estate litigation?Estate litigation is also commonly referred to as “probate litigation.” In short, this involves a legal dispute over the probate process. In other words, an estate litigation lawsuit is a formal legal objection over the way assets or inheritance is being handled or distributed from a deceased individual’s estate.

When can an estate be disputed?
Estates may be contested when an “interested party” has a formal legal objection over the way the estate is being administered.

Interested parties may include: beneficiaries of the estate, beneficiaries who were unlawfully removed, creditors, relatives of the estate.

What if someone dies without a will or estate plan?
When someone dies without an estate plan dictating their final wishes, their property becomes intestate under Michigan law. This means property that is not exempt from probate goes to the closest family members of the deceased.

Michigan probate courts have a specific legal process in determining the closest family members. We explain this process in further detail in our article on Intestate Succession.

What is the difference between probate and estate litigation?
There’s a lot of overlap between these two practice areas; however, probate is a more broad term that encompass any legal matter related to assets of a deceased person. On the other hand, estate litigation is more specialized in that it deals with legal disputes over said assets.

Do I need a lawyer?
Yes, in cases where an estate is being contested in court, legal representation is required. These cases are often highly complex and emotion; thus, it’s advised to use an experienced probate an estate lawyer who specializes in litigation cases to ensure your legal rights are protected.